Great discussion going over at WTT:RP too. Go check that out.
Back when she was still actively blogging, the lovely Bre introduced me to a concept that I like quite a lot.
“That elusive piece of loot, that one single object that if you finally, finally receive, will make all your in-game dreams come true. That item that turns you from a nice, loving individual to a raving lunatic. That item that when won will wipe frustrations and disappointments to nothing. All those runs, and countless wipes will disappear the moment that illustrious item makes its way into your bags.”
For me, it’s rarely been a single item (though Hakkar’s main hand axe was definitely one). In fact, it’s not even been a single instance. For me, the loot unicorn which taunts me, peeks at me through the trees and then disappears whenever I try to get a better look?
I ran Karazhan for close to a year, got myself a PVP shield (since you BUY those, they don’t DROP), and was happily hurtling towards Mount Hyjal before I saw the Triptych Shield of the Ancients drop from the Chess event. I figured I’d just gotten supremely unlucky, until my Paladin had similar (though not quite as extended) trouble getting that shield to drop.
Enter Game Reboot Lich King
I level the Paladin to 80 and start running Naxx, scraping together enough Badges of Heroism to buy the spellpower shield. And until yesterday, the only other shield I have ever seen drop with spellpower on it would’ve been a downgrade (and thus got passed to our lovely Resto Shaman). Months of Naxx, and TRI did not get a single Voice of Reason drop. And now three months of running Ulduar 10, and though some affiliated raids have been passing out Pulsing Spellshields like candy, my 10 man has never seen it drop.
Until very recently, even my Shaman was healing with a spellhit offhand fob instead of a spellpower shield (though I finally got her enough badges to wear the same one, in her Naxx10/25 mishmash as my full Ulduar paladin was wearing).
And then yesterday I get invited to tag along to the tail end of a short-handed Naxx 25 run, just to clear out the last four bosses. I figure, why not – chances are chances, right?
And I love it. Cement skulls, glowy eyeballs, creepy teeth and all.
In an attempt to clarify my previously stated position on the possibility of Goblins and Worgen as potential new playable races in WoW (apparently some of you are surprised that I’d make a blanket statement without elaboration) I am posting here my opinion on this particular subject. So without further ado, a full on Anna-rant.
Let’s start with the obvious here, ok?
Worgen are a mutual enemy of both factions.
Goblins are a neutral ally to both factions.
Blizzard is now having to face the faction problem. How do you solve the faction problem? Well there’s the potential for two “new” factions – since allying them together is totally out of left field (since when to Goblins ally with anyone?) and makes no sense. But two new factions means new factions to balance (and Goblins already ARE a faction).
Nor does it make sense that either the Horde or the Alliance will magically start loving Worgen (see: Duskwood/Silverpine) or that Goblins will magically decide to start loving the Horde to the exclusion of the Alliance or vice versa (see: Gold Grubbing McGreedyPants). In fact, we can gain reputation with THEM – which, at the current time serves only to make THEM more money, since we do more stuff for them.
The closest to “makes sense” in either race is having Goblins be able to choose Horde OR Alliance, based on some arbitrary decision that they only want half of the gold (what goblin only wants half of the gold?) – and doing so would require twice the quest coding for Goblins alone, as well as allowing one/both races to be either faction, something Blizzard has actively shunned.
Having Goblins act as cross-faction allies – while admittedly a neat concept – doesn’t fit at all with any of the history of Blizzard’s decisions regarding cross faction communication. They’re actively promoting the difference between Horde and Alliance (T9, Isle of Conquest), not building bridges.
All of which still leaves out WTF to do with these Worgen guys that want to eat your children and/or turn them into more Worgen.
Basically, I don’t see that it can work without creating an entirely new lore base and retconning a bunch of already existing history with these two races. And given past experiences, I am extremely dubious that they will do even a remotely good job. The Draenei thing was pretty awful, and I /like/ Draenei – their saving grace is that they just flat didn’t exist in game before Burning Crusade, and so were quite the blank slate to work with, lore wise. DK’s are hard enough to deal with, ICly, and they too (even though they’re a class, not a race) had no actual in game presence.
I honestly don’t see that either race provides anything even remotely interesting as a PC that they don’t already provide as an NPC, unless it’s to cater to people that want to be Wolf-men and Gobbos.
It doesn’t add any great depth to the lore. It doesn’t add any great explanation of some long unexplained race (Furbolg anyone? Now that’s a race that at least has some options for lore background with it). It adds Goblins and Worgen into the game for some arbitrary reason. I know that some people are SOO EXCITED OMFG at a chance to play Gobbos and Wolf-men. That does not make either Goblins OR Worgen make sense as a playable race.
And all that aside – I know that for Burning Crusade, the addition of the new Hallow’s End masks were signifiers for the new race – but what’s to say they don’t just have SCARY THING masks for dressing up this year?
I will be actively moderating posts in light that this is obviously a sensitive issue. Keep it civil – you’re free to argue, as always.
*Artwork by the amazing Katharsis
- Siha has a fantastic post today And I’m quite thankful for it, I think. She outlines exactly how to calculate the extent of the Paladin healing nerfs in relation to the buffs involved. I’ve done the math for my last Ulduar 10 and Ulduar 25 runs. This week I’ll be running with a different spec (54/17/0) just to see what happens, as that’s the spec I want to eventually use in 3.2 (I think). I’ll re-crunch the numbers after this week’s raids, in an effort to postpone weeping all over my desk.
- That is, if the instance servers are actually UP during raid time this week. After three of the other officers and I cobbled a 25 man raid together through sheer force of will last Thursday, it was highly discouraging to have it go up in flames thanks to the server.
- I need more tea.
- I am not good at reading. Or I’m too good at reading. I’m not sure. Either way, I just finally have been able to read fiction again, thanks to many of the WFR folks at Feathermeet, and I’m out of practice. Namely with things like “No, doofus, do not start a book at 10pm, you will be up until 2:30am finishing it in one go”. (if you like historical fiction, you should check out Graham’sBlack Ships )
- I think the idea of playable goblins and worgen is stupid. I realize this makes at least half of you want to shoot me. Do not turn the comments into an argument about why I’m wrong. I will still think they’re stupid. Feel free to talk about this change with someone more open to discussion.
- After spending our second weekend in a row out of town, my cats have resorted to sitting on me whenever I am sitting down, apparently because they think this will make me not leave them alone anymore.
- This is almost as good as tea
So I’m not really in a position where I should be creating alts. This, of course, does nothing to deter me from making alts when the inspiration strikes. I’ve been really enjoying my Alliance hunter, and she’s my raiding main …
The cathedral bells stop ringing overnight, except for chiming the hours. Three bell strikes, and Angoleth padded softly around another corner of the Cathedral District, staying carefully in the shadows. Trained ears picked up Mogget’s soft breathing – nearly inaudible …
(Written by Jolly, Tarquin, and Annalea)
The highlands of Lordaeron were not for the faint of heart; be it the putrescence of the Scourge’s long-lingering remnant, or the rock-strewn hills and valleys that made farmers out of only the most …
(With Tarquin and Annalea)
Once more, four people made their way through the thickets and hills of Lordaeron, this time in the crisp chill of late morning, seeking after the Rider. Aelflaed had snatched what sleep she could while Chryste …
She hadn’t wanted to leave Jolly – not so soon after finding him again – but once away, it took about five minutes for Aely to figure out she had a problem.
That problem had just announced that …
It was an uneasy goodbye for him, but it was agreed by both he and Aely that a stroll back to Hearthglen would not be very easy to explain, nor would the explanation needed for the three Argent soldiers once …
“Light sent me ye when I needed ye afore – an’ now again when I need ye. I canna ask fir more than tha’.” She sighed and slung the shield back across her shoulders. “It’s… Light. Been awhile hasna it? …